Is an Array or an Object More Efficient for Retrieving Objects by ID in JavaScript?

Array vs. Object Efficiency in JavaScript: A Comprehensive Analysis

When working with large datasets in JavaScript, it becomes essential to consider the efficiency of data storage and retrieval methods. This article delves into the topic of array vs. object efficiency, addressing a specific scenario where retrieval by ID is a primary concern.

Arrays vs. Objects: Understanding the Differences

Despite common perceptions, JavaScript does not offer associative arrays. Instead, arrays and objects fulfill different roles:

Arrays:

• Are ordered collections of values, accessible via numerical indices.
• Are designed for storing ordered data sequences.

Objects:

• Are unordered collections of key-value pairs.
• Are suitable for representing data structured as properties and values.

Storage Options: Exploring Array and Object Approaches

To store and retrieve individual objects efficiently, two primary options arise:

Option 1: Array with Non-Associative Indexes

Objects are stored in an array with incrementing numerical indices.

let array = [{ id: 29938, name: 'name1' }, { id: 32994, name: 'name1' }];
function getObject(id) {
  for (let i = 0; i < array.length; i++) {
    if (array[i].id === id) {
      return array[i];
    }
  }
}

Option 2: Object with Key-Value Pairs

Objects are stored in an object using their ID as the key.

let obj = {};
obj[29938] = { id: 29938, name: 'name1' };
obj[32994] = { id: 32994, name: 'name1' };
function getObject(id) {
  return obj[id];
}

Performance Analysis: Benchmarking the Options

To evaluate the efficiency, we conduct performance tests involving the following:

• Randomly generated object IDs ranging from 10,000 to 60,000.
• Creation of an array with non-associative indices, a holey array, and an object with key-value pairs.
• Multiple iterations of object retrieval by ID.

Test Results:

• In the majority of cases, arrays performed faster than objects for object retrieval by ID.
• Using a holey array significantly impacted performance compared to a continuous array.
• Sorting operations would change the efficiency balance, but the general trend of arrays being faster remains.

Conclusion

Based on the performance tests, arrays emerge as a more efficient choice for storing and retrieving individual objects by ID, especially in scenarios where retrieval operations are prevalent. Objects, on the other hand, offer advantages in data representation where properties and values are better suited for the unordered nature of objects.

The above is the detailed content of Is an Array or an Object More Efficient for Retrieving Objects by ID in JavaScript?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!