Table of Contents
Microsoft Visual C 's Misunderstood "Broken" Two-Phase Template Instantiation
Home Backend Development C++ Is Microsoft Visual C 's Two-Phase Template Instantiation Truly Broken, and If So, How?

Is Microsoft Visual C 's Two-Phase Template Instantiation Truly Broken, and If So, How?

Dec 07, 2024 pm 12:13 PM

Is Microsoft Visual C  's Two-Phase Template Instantiation Truly Broken, and If So, How?

Microsoft Visual C 's Misunderstood "Broken" Two-Phase Template Instantiation

Introduction

Microsoft Visual C (MSVC) has often been criticized for its alleged flawed implementation of two-phase template instantiation. This article delves into the specifics of this criticism, examining the underlying issue and providing a detailed explanation.

The Two-Phase Template Instantiation Controversy

Two-phase template instantiation is a process in C where template classes and functions are first syntactically checked for correctness, and then complete instantiation occurs at later usage sites. However, claims have been made that MSVC does not properly implement this mechanism.

Early Understanding of the Issue

Initially, it was believed that MSVC only performed basic syntax checks on template definitions, ignoring whether names used in the template were declared. However, this understanding is incomplete.

The True Nature of the Issue

The actual issue with MSVC's two-phase template instantiation comprises two interconnected layers:

Layer 1: Incorrect First Phase Lookup

MSVC fails to perform early (first phase) lookup for non-dependent expressions, such as in the example:

int foo(void*);

template<typename T> struct S {
  S() { int i = foo(0); }
};

void foo(int);
Copy after login

MSVC postpones this lookup to the second phase, where it mistakenly binds the expression to 'foo(int)', resulting in an error.

Layer 2: Incorrect Second Phase Lookup

The second phase of template lookup in MSVC is also flawed. While the C standard specifies that ADL-nominated namespaces are extended in the second phase, MSVC erroneously extends non-ADL lookup as well.

This can be illustrated with the following example:

namespace N {
  struct S {};
}

void bar(void *) {}

template <typename T> void foo(T *t) {
  bar(t);
}

void bar(N::S *s) {}
Copy after login

Despite being dependent, the call to bar(t) is incorrectly resolved to void bar(N::S *s), demonstrating the improper behavior of MSVC's second phase lookup.

Conclusion

Microsoft Visual C 's implementation of two-phase template instantiation is indeed flawed, but not in the simplistic manner originally understood. The issue is a complex interplay between incorrect first and second phase lookups that can result in errors or incorrect behavior for certain code constructions.

The above is the detailed content of Is Microsoft Visual C 's Two-Phase Template Instantiation Truly Broken, and If So, How?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Statement of this Website
The content of this article is voluntarily contributed by netizens, and the copyright belongs to the original author. This site does not assume corresponding legal responsibility. If you find any content suspected of plagiarism or infringement, please contact admin@php.cn

Hot Article

Hot tools Tags

Notepad++7.3.1

Notepad++7.3.1

Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version

SublimeText3 Chinese version

Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6

Dreamweaver CS6

Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version

SublimeText3 Mac version

God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

C language function format letter case conversion steps C language function format letter case conversion steps Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:53 PM

C language function format letter case conversion steps

Gulc: C library built from scratch Gulc: C library built from scratch Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:46 PM

Gulc: C library built from scratch

What are the types of values ​​returned by c language functions? What determines the return value? What are the types of values ​​returned by c language functions? What determines the return value? Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:52 PM

What are the types of values ​​returned by c language functions? What determines the return value?

What are the definitions and calling rules of c language functions and what are the What are the definitions and calling rules of c language functions and what are the Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:53 PM

What are the definitions and calling rules of c language functions and what are the

How does the C   Standard Template Library (STL) work? How does the C Standard Template Library (STL) work? Mar 12, 2025 pm 04:50 PM

How does the C Standard Template Library (STL) work?

Where is the return value of the c language function stored in memory? Where is the return value of the c language function stored in memory? Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:51 PM

Where is the return value of the c language function stored in memory?

distinct usage and phrase sharing distinct usage and phrase sharing Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:51 PM

distinct usage and phrase sharing

What is the minimum common multiple of the maximum common divisor of a c language function? What is the minimum common multiple of the maximum common divisor of a c language function? Mar 03, 2025 pm 05:55 PM

What is the minimum common multiple of the maximum common divisor of a c language function?

See all articles