Why Does C \'s Modulo Operator Produce Negative Results?

Negative Output from Modulo in C

In C , using the modulo operator (%) on negative numbers can yield unexpected results compared to mathematical expectations. Whereas Python consistently returns non-negative values, C allows negative outputs. This behavior stems from the implementation of integer division and modulo operations in C .

According to the ISO/IEC 14882 standard for C , the behavior of the modulo operator is implementation-defined if the second operand is zero. For non-zero operands, the standard states that:

• The quotient (from the division) will be rounded towards zero.
• The division equation holds: (a / b) * b a % b = a.

Consequently, if the second operand is positive and the first operand is negative, the quotient will be negative. This leads to the negative output observed in C 's modulo operation.

This design decision was likely influenced by several factors:

• Processor Architecture: Integer division and modulo are often performed as a single operation on processors (e.g., idiv on x86), which prioritizes efficiency (in the common case of division) over mathematical precision.
• Consistency: The rounding toward zero behavior is consistent with other aspects of integer division in C .
• Performance: Using a single operation for both division and modulo simplifies implementation and can improve performance.
• Compatibility: C maintains compatibility with C, which also has this behavior.

Despite the standard allowing for this implementation-defined behavior, it can be confusing for some users. However, understanding the rationale behind this design choice can help clarify the expected outcomes when using the modulo operator in C .

The above is the detailed content of Why Does C \'s Modulo Operator Produce Negative Results?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!