Why Shouldn't You Inherit from Standard Containers?

Inheriting Standard Containers: A Pitfall to Avoid

While the idea of extending standard containers by inheritance may seem appealing, it's a practice that should be approached with caution. There are several compelling reasons why subclassing or inheriting from standard containers is generally inadvisable:

Lack of Virtual Destructors:

Standard containers typically do not have virtual destructors, which poses a significant issue for polymorphic use. Without virtual destructors, derived classes cannot guarantee proper cleanup when objects are destroyed.

Poor Design Principle:

Inheriting from standard containers violates good encapsulation principles. Extensions should be implemented externally through generic algorithms rather than internal inheritance. Generic algorithms provide greater code reuse and maintain a clean design.

Misinterpretation of Inheritance:

It's crucial to understand that inheritance is not a suitable mechanism for extending behavior. Inheritance introduces unnecessary coupling and limits future design flexibility. Composition should be preferred over inheritance whenever possible.

Composition as an Alternative:

Instead of inheriting from standard containers, consider using composition. A custom class can contain a standard container and provide additional functionality without violating encapsulation. This approach maintains flexibility and allows for easier maintenance.

In summary, inheriting standard containers is generally not recommended due to the lack of virtual destructors, poor design principles, and the misuse of inheritance for behavior extension. Composition provides a superior alternative for extending container functionality while preserving encapsulation and design flexibility.

The above is the detailed content of Why Shouldn't You Inherit from Standard Containers?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!