Table of Contents
Why are elementwise additions much faster in separate loops than in a combined loop?
Initial Question
Question:
Answer:
Cache Behavior Analysis
Architectural Differences
Home Backend Development C++ Why are elementwise additions faster in separate loops than in a single loop, considering cache behavior?

Why are elementwise additions faster in separate loops than in a single loop, considering cache behavior?

Jan 04, 2025 am 09:14 AM

Why are elementwise additions faster in separate loops than in a single loop, considering cache behavior?

Why are elementwise additions much faster in separate loops than in a combined loop?

Initially, the question was posed regarding the performance difference between elementwise additions performed in a combined loop versus separate loops. However, it was later modified to seek insights into the cache behaviors that lead to these performance variations.

Initial Question

Question:

Why are elementwise additions significantly faster in separate loops than in a combined loop?

Answer:

Upon further analysis, it is believed that this behavior is caused by data alignment issues with the four pointers used in the operation, potentially resulting in cache bank/way conflicts. Specifically, it is likely that the arrays are allocated on the same page line, leading to accesses within each loop falling on the same cache way. This is less efficient than distributing the accesses across multiple cache ways, which is possible when the arrays are allocated separately.

Cache Behavior Analysis

Question:

Could you provide some solid insight into the details that lead to the different cache behaviors as illustrated by the five regions in the graph?

Answer:

Region 1: The dataset is so small that performance is dominated by overhead, such as looping and branching, rather than cache behavior.

Region 2: Previously attributed to alignment issues, further analysis suggests that the performance drop in this region needs further investigation. Cache bank conflicts could still be a factor.

Region 3: The data size exceeds the L1 cache capacity, leading to performance limitations imposed by the L1 to L2 cache bandwidth.

Region 4: The performance penalty observed in the single-loop version is likely due to false aliasing stalls in the processor's load/store units caused by the alignment of the arrays. False aliasing occurs when the processor speculatively executes load operations and encounters a second load to the same address with a different value. In this case, the processor must discard the speculative load and reload the correct value, leading to a performance penalty.

Region 5: At this point, the data size exceeds the capacity of both the L1 and L2 caches, resulting in performance limitations imposed by memory bandwidth.

Architectural Differences

Question:

It might also be interesting to point out the differences between CPU/cache architectures, by providing a similar graph for these CPUs.

Answer:

The provided graph represents data collected from two Intel Xeon X5482 Harpertown processors at 3.2 GHz. Similar tests on other architectures, such as the Intel Core i7 870 @ 2.8 GHz and the Intel Core i7 2600K @ 4.4 GHz, produce graphs that exhibit similar regions, although the specific performance values may vary. These variations can be attributed to differences in cache sizes, memory bandwidth, and other architectural features.

The above is the detailed content of Why are elementwise additions faster in separate loops than in a single loop, considering cache behavior?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Statement of this Website
The content of this article is voluntarily contributed by netizens, and the copyright belongs to the original author. This site does not assume corresponding legal responsibility. If you find any content suspected of plagiarism or infringement, please contact admin@php.cn

Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress

Undresser.AI Undress

AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover

AI Clothes Remover

Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool

Undress AI Tool

Undress images for free

Clothoff.io

Clothoff.io

AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap

Video Face Swap

Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1

Notepad++7.3.1

Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version

SublimeText3 Chinese version

Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6

Dreamweaver CS6

Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version

SublimeText3 Mac version

God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

C language data structure: data representation and operation of trees and graphs C language data structure: data representation and operation of trees and graphs Apr 04, 2025 am 11:18 AM

C language data structure: The data representation of the tree and graph is a hierarchical data structure consisting of nodes. Each node contains a data element and a pointer to its child nodes. The binary tree is a special type of tree. Each node has at most two child nodes. The data represents structTreeNode{intdata;structTreeNode*left;structTreeNode*right;}; Operation creates a tree traversal tree (predecision, in-order, and later order) search tree insertion node deletes node graph is a collection of data structures, where elements are vertices, and they can be connected together through edges with right or unrighted data representing neighbors.

The truth behind the C language file operation problem The truth behind the C language file operation problem Apr 04, 2025 am 11:24 AM

The truth about file operation problems: file opening failed: insufficient permissions, wrong paths, and file occupied. Data writing failed: the buffer is full, the file is not writable, and the disk space is insufficient. Other FAQs: slow file traversal, incorrect text file encoding, and binary file reading errors.

What are the basic requirements for c language functions What are the basic requirements for c language functions Apr 03, 2025 pm 10:06 PM

C language functions are the basis for code modularization and program building. They consist of declarations (function headers) and definitions (function bodies). C language uses values ​​to pass parameters by default, but external variables can also be modified using address pass. Functions can have or have no return value, and the return value type must be consistent with the declaration. Function naming should be clear and easy to understand, using camel or underscore nomenclature. Follow the single responsibility principle and keep the function simplicity to improve maintainability and readability.

Function name definition in c language Function name definition in c language Apr 03, 2025 pm 10:03 PM

The C language function name definition includes: return value type, function name, parameter list and function body. Function names should be clear, concise and unified in style to avoid conflicts with keywords. Function names have scopes and can be used after declaration. Function pointers allow functions to be passed or assigned as arguments. Common errors include naming conflicts, mismatch of parameter types, and undeclared functions. Performance optimization focuses on function design and implementation, while clear and easy-to-read code is crucial.

Concept of c language function Concept of c language function Apr 03, 2025 pm 10:09 PM

C language functions are reusable code blocks. They receive input, perform operations, and return results, which modularly improves reusability and reduces complexity. The internal mechanism of the function includes parameter passing, function execution, and return values. The entire process involves optimization such as function inline. A good function is written following the principle of single responsibility, small number of parameters, naming specifications, and error handling. Pointers combined with functions can achieve more powerful functions, such as modifying external variable values. Function pointers pass functions as parameters or store addresses, and are used to implement dynamic calls to functions. Understanding function features and techniques is the key to writing efficient, maintainable, and easy to understand C programs.

How to calculate c-subscript 3 subscript 5 c-subscript 3 subscript 5 algorithm tutorial How to calculate c-subscript 3 subscript 5 c-subscript 3 subscript 5 algorithm tutorial Apr 03, 2025 pm 10:33 PM

The calculation of C35 is essentially combinatorial mathematics, representing the number of combinations selected from 3 of 5 elements. The calculation formula is C53 = 5! / (3! * 2!), which can be directly calculated by loops to improve efficiency and avoid overflow. In addition, understanding the nature of combinations and mastering efficient calculation methods is crucial to solving many problems in the fields of probability statistics, cryptography, algorithm design, etc.

CS-Week 3 CS-Week 3 Apr 04, 2025 am 06:06 AM

Algorithms are the set of instructions to solve problems, and their execution speed and memory usage vary. In programming, many algorithms are based on data search and sorting. This article will introduce several data retrieval and sorting algorithms. Linear search assumes that there is an array [20,500,10,5,100,1,50] and needs to find the number 50. The linear search algorithm checks each element in the array one by one until the target value is found or the complete array is traversed. The algorithm flowchart is as follows: The pseudo-code for linear search is as follows: Check each element: If the target value is found: Return true Return false C language implementation: #include#includeintmain(void){i

C# vs. C  : History, Evolution, and Future Prospects C# vs. C : History, Evolution, and Future Prospects Apr 19, 2025 am 12:07 AM

The history and evolution of C# and C are unique, and the future prospects are also different. 1.C was invented by BjarneStroustrup in 1983 to introduce object-oriented programming into the C language. Its evolution process includes multiple standardizations, such as C 11 introducing auto keywords and lambda expressions, C 20 introducing concepts and coroutines, and will focus on performance and system-level programming in the future. 2.C# was released by Microsoft in 2000. Combining the advantages of C and Java, its evolution focuses on simplicity and productivity. For example, C#2.0 introduced generics and C#5.0 introduced asynchronous programming, which will focus on developers' productivity and cloud computing in the future.

See all articles