Is std::vector Really Slower Than Arrays?

std::vector Performance Comparison

The performance of std::vector has always been a subject of debate in the programming community. While it's generally believed that std::vector is implemented as an array, recent tests have raised questions about its actual performance.

Test Results

A series of tests were conducted using the code provided in the question. The results were surprising:

• UseArray: 2.619 seconds
• UseVector: 9.284 seconds
• UseVectorPushBack: 14.669 seconds

These results show that std::vector is significantly slower than arrays, roughly three to four times slower.

Analysis

Upon examining the test code, it was discovered that the tests were unfair. std::vector was being traversed twice, while the array was only traversed once. This additional traversal significantly impacted the performance of std::vector.

Optimized Vector Implementation

To provide a fairer comparison, the vector code was optimized to initialize each object only once:

std::vector<Pixel> pixels(dimensions * dimensions, Pixel(255, 0, 0));

With this optimization, the performance of std::vector improved significantly:

• UseVector: 2.216 seconds

Conclusion

The initial tests showed a significant performance difference between std::vector and arrays. However, after optimizing the vector code, the performance gap narrowed dramatically. While std::vector is still slightly slower than arrays, the difference is negligible for most practical applications.

It's important to note that the performance of std::vector may vary depending on the specific compiler and platform used. However, the results presented here provide a reasonable comparison of the performance of std::vector and arrays in a specific context.

The above is the detailed content of Is std::vector Really Slower Than Arrays?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!