Why Can't You Use `await` Inside a `lock` Statement in C#?

The reason why the use of lock is prohibited within the await statement in C#

In C#, the await operator cannot be used inside a lock statement, which is a deliberate design choice made by the compiler team. While implementing this functionality is not difficult, it is considered a dangerous practice that can lead to deadlocks.

The reason behind the restriction

Allowing the use of lock within a await statement results in the execution of arbitrary code between the time when await releases control and the method's subsequent resumption. This code may acquire locks in an order that conflicts with the original lock hierarchy, causing a deadlock.

Additionally, await execution may resume on a different thread than the one that originally acquired the lock. This leads to the possibility of unlocking the lock on a different thread than the one that acquired the lock, which is highly undesirable.

Impact on custom lock implementation

Attempts to circumvent this limitation using a custom lock implementation (such as the one provided in the given code example) may result in unpredictable and potentially deadlock-prone behavior. This is because the await call in the ExitDisposable class may block indefinitely if another thread acquires the lock while the Monitor.Exit operation is in progress.

Conclusion

While the await operator provides powerful asynchronous programming capabilities, it is important to understand the importance of following recommended best practices, including prohibiting the use of lock within a await statement. This restriction is intended to prevent deadlocks and ensure the safety and reliability of multithreaded code.

The above is the detailed content of Why Can't You Use `await` Inside a `lock` Statement in C#?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!