Table of Contents
1 The first pit: Wrong lock release timing
1.1. Found the problem
1.2 Solve the problem
2 The second pit: cache invalidation problem
2.1 Expiration cleanup mechanism
2.2 Memory recycling mechanism
2.3 Optimistic lock
Home Database Redis What are the two pitfalls that Redis distributed locks must avoid?

What are the two pitfalls that Redis distributed locks must avoid?

May 29, 2023 pm 10:52 PM
redis

1 The first pit: Wrong lock release timing

1.1. Found the problem

Analyze the problems in the following code:

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

// 分布式锁服务

public interface RedisLockService {

    // 获取锁

    public boolean getLock(String key);

    // 释放锁

    public boolean releaseLock(String key);

}

 

// 业务服务

public class BizService {

 

    @Resource

    private RedisLockService redisLockService;

 

    public void bizMethod(String bizId) {

        try {

            // 获取锁

            if(redisLockService.getLock(bizId)) {

                // 业务重复校验

                if(!bizValidate(bizId)) {

                    throw new BizException(ErrorBizCode.REPEATED);

                }

                // 执行业务

                return doBusiness();

            }

            // 获取锁失败

            throw new BizException(ErrorBizCode.GET_LOCK_ERROR);

        } finally {

            // 释放锁

            redisLockService.releaseLock(bizId);

        }

    }

}

Copy after login

The above code seems to be fine, In fact, it hides a big problem. The problem is that when releasing the lock, there is no verification whether the current thread has obtained the lock:

  • Thread 1 and Thread 2 access the business method at the same time

  • Thread 2 Obtain the lock successfully and perform business processing

  • Thread 1 did not acquire the lock, but released the lock successfully

  • At this time, thread 3 tried to acquire The lock is successful, but the business of Thread 2 has not been processed, so Thread 3 will not cause a business duplication exception

  • Ultimately, Thread 2 and Thread 3 will repeatedly execute the business

1.2 Solve the problem

The solution is to allow the lock to be released only after confirming that the lock acquisition is successful:

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

public class BizService {

 

    @Resource

    private RedisLockService redisLockService;

 

    public void bizMethod(String bizId) {

        boolean getLockSuccess = false;

        try {

            // 尝试获取锁

            getLockSuccess = redisLockService.getLock(bizId);

            // 获取锁成功

            if(getLockSuccess) {

                // 业务重复校验

                if(!bizValidate(bizId)) {

                    throw new BizException(ErrorBizCode.REPEATED);

                }

                // 执行业务

                return doBusiness();

            }

            // 获取锁失败

            throw new BizException(ErrorBizCode.GET_LOCK_ERROR);

        } finally {

            // 获取锁成功才允许释放锁

            if(getLockSuccess) {

                redisLockService.releaseLock(bizId);

            }

        }

    }

}

Copy after login

2 The second pit: cache invalidation problem

No. The second problem is that Redis also has a memory cleaning mechanism, which may cause distributed locks to fail.

2.1 Expiration cleanup mechanism

(1) Regular deletion

Redis regularly checks which keys have expired, and deletes them if they are found to be expired

(2) Lazy deletion

If there are too many keys, regular deletion will consume a lot of resources, so a lazy deletion strategy is introduced

If Redis finds that the key has expired when accessing it, Direct deletion

2.2 Memory recycling mechanism

When memory is insufficient, Redis will select some elements for deletion:

no-enviction

Prohibit eviction of data, new The write operation will report an error

volatile-lru

Select the least recently used data from the data set with an expiration time to be eliminated

volatile-ttl

Select the data to be expired from the data set with expiration time set to be eliminated

volatile-random

Select any data to be eliminated from the data set with expiration time set

allkeys- lru

Select the least recently used data from the data set to eliminate

allkeys-random

Select any data from the data set to eliminate

There are at least two Scenario causes distributed lock failure problem:

  • Scenario 1: Redis has insufficient memory for memory recycling, use allkeys-lru or allkeys-random The recycling strategy causes lock failure

  • Scenario 2: The thread successfully acquires the distributed lock, but the processing time is too long. At this time, the lock expires and is regularly cleared, causing other threads to successfully acquire the lock and fail. Repeated execution of business

2.3 Optimistic lock

The general solution is to protect it at the database layer. For example, the inventory deduction business uses optimistic locking at the database layer.

1

2

udpate goods set stock = stock - #{acquire}

where sku_id = #{skuId} and stock - #{acquire} >= 0

Copy after login

The above is the detailed content of What are the two pitfalls that Redis distributed locks must avoid?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Statement of this Website
The content of this article is voluntarily contributed by netizens, and the copyright belongs to the original author. This site does not assume corresponding legal responsibility. If you find any content suspected of plagiarism or infringement, please contact admin@php.cn

Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress

Undresser.AI Undress

AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover

AI Clothes Remover

Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool

Undress AI Tool

Undress images for free

Clothoff.io

Clothoff.io

AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap

Video Face Swap

Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1

Notepad++7.3.1

Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version

SublimeText3 Chinese version

Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6

Dreamweaver CS6

Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version

SublimeText3 Mac version

God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

How to build the redis cluster mode How to build the redis cluster mode Apr 10, 2025 pm 10:15 PM

Redis cluster mode deploys Redis instances to multiple servers through sharding, improving scalability and availability. The construction steps are as follows: Create odd Redis instances with different ports; Create 3 sentinel instances, monitor Redis instances and failover; configure sentinel configuration files, add monitoring Redis instance information and failover settings; configure Redis instance configuration files, enable cluster mode and specify the cluster information file path; create nodes.conf file, containing information of each Redis instance; start the cluster, execute the create command to create a cluster and specify the number of replicas; log in to the cluster to execute the CLUSTER INFO command to verify the cluster status; make

How to clear redis data How to clear redis data Apr 10, 2025 pm 10:06 PM

How to clear Redis data: Use the FLUSHALL command to clear all key values. Use the FLUSHDB command to clear the key value of the currently selected database. Use SELECT to switch databases, and then use FLUSHDB to clear multiple databases. Use the DEL command to delete a specific key. Use the redis-cli tool to clear the data.

How to read redis queue How to read redis queue Apr 10, 2025 pm 10:12 PM

To read a queue from Redis, you need to get the queue name, read the elements using the LPOP command, and process the empty queue. The specific steps are as follows: Get the queue name: name it with the prefix of "queue:" such as "queue:my-queue". Use the LPOP command: Eject the element from the head of the queue and return its value, such as LPOP queue:my-queue. Processing empty queues: If the queue is empty, LPOP returns nil, and you can check whether the queue exists before reading the element.

How to use the redis command How to use the redis command Apr 10, 2025 pm 08:45 PM

Using the Redis directive requires the following steps: Open the Redis client. Enter the command (verb key value). Provides the required parameters (varies from instruction to instruction). Press Enter to execute the command. Redis returns a response indicating the result of the operation (usually OK or -ERR).

How to use redis lock How to use redis lock Apr 10, 2025 pm 08:39 PM

Using Redis to lock operations requires obtaining the lock through the SETNX command, and then using the EXPIRE command to set the expiration time. The specific steps are: (1) Use the SETNX command to try to set a key-value pair; (2) Use the EXPIRE command to set the expiration time for the lock; (3) Use the DEL command to delete the lock when the lock is no longer needed.

How to configure Lua script execution time in centos redis How to configure Lua script execution time in centos redis Apr 14, 2025 pm 02:12 PM

On CentOS systems, you can limit the execution time of Lua scripts by modifying Redis configuration files or using Redis commands to prevent malicious scripts from consuming too much resources. Method 1: Modify the Redis configuration file and locate the Redis configuration file: The Redis configuration file is usually located in /etc/redis/redis.conf. Edit configuration file: Open the configuration file using a text editor (such as vi or nano): sudovi/etc/redis/redis.conf Set the Lua script execution time limit: Add or modify the following lines in the configuration file to set the maximum execution time of the Lua script (unit: milliseconds)

How to use the redis command line How to use the redis command line Apr 10, 2025 pm 10:18 PM

Use the Redis command line tool (redis-cli) to manage and operate Redis through the following steps: Connect to the server, specify the address and port. Send commands to the server using the command name and parameters. Use the HELP command to view help information for a specific command. Use the QUIT command to exit the command line tool.

How to optimize the performance of debian readdir How to optimize the performance of debian readdir Apr 13, 2025 am 08:48 AM

In Debian systems, readdir system calls are used to read directory contents. If its performance is not good, try the following optimization strategy: Simplify the number of directory files: Split large directories into multiple small directories as much as possible, reducing the number of items processed per readdir call. Enable directory content caching: build a cache mechanism, update the cache regularly or when directory content changes, and reduce frequent calls to readdir. Memory caches (such as Memcached or Redis) or local caches (such as files or databases) can be considered. Adopt efficient data structure: If you implement directory traversal by yourself, select more efficient data structures (such as hash tables instead of linear search) to store and access directory information

See all articles