

Coinbase is caught in a litigation whirlpool: background of the case, details of the judgment and future direction
On March 27, Judge Katherine Polk Failla of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed most of Coinbase’s motions, holding that Coinbase, as an unregistered exchange, broker and clearing agency, was incompatible with An institution under the federal securities laws and engages in the unregistered offering and sale of securities through its pledge program. However, the court rejected the SEC’s claim that Coinbase was acting as an unregistered broker by making its wallet app available to customers.
Original text of the judgment:
https://plum-harrietta-82.tiiny.site/
References:
https://www. coindesk.com/policy/2024/03/27/coinbase-loses-most-of-motion-to-dismiss-sec-lawsuit/?utm_medium=referral&utm_source=rss&utm_campaign=headlines
Case Background
SEC filed a lawsuit against Coinbase on June 6, 2023, accusing it of violating federal securities laws by providing trading and staking services to the public. It also believes that Coinbase Wallet acted as an unregistered brokerage firm. Require Coinbase to return illegal profits and pay corresponding pre-judgment compensation information, impose civil penalties on Coinbase, and grant any compensation measures that may be appropriate to protect the interests of investors.
On June 29, 2023, Coinbase stated in response to the SEC’s lawsuit that the cryptocurrencies listed by the SEC were not investment contracts and therefore were not securities and did not fall within the scope of its supervision. Coinbase also said that its due process rights were violated when the SEC filed the lawsuit and that the SEC's lawsuit may have violated the "material issues" doctrine.
On August 4, 2023, Coinbase submitted documents to formally respond to the SEC’s lawsuit, alleging that the regulatory agency went far beyond its jurisdiction. Coinbase countered in the filing that the SEC did not claim the examples involved investment contracts or contracts for the future value of assets. Transactions on the Coinbase platform and Prime are not and do not involve the provision of contracts that reflect the future value of a business's revenue, profits, or assets. They are sales of goods and the obligations of both parties are completely released once the cryptographic tokens are delivered in exchange for payment.
On October 25, 2023, Coinbase filed a case response brief and stated in the document that because the SEC’s complaint did not and could not argue that the simple asset transactions it determined involved ongoing contractual obligations related to the enterprise, it Coinbase reserves the right to make a judgment on the complaint. The SEC's view that any purchase by a buyer seeking to obtain increased value constitutes an investment contract, and therefore a security, is an attempt to fundamentally expand its own powers and, as the material issues doctrine makes clear, is material if an institution wants to Decisions on issues must be supported by clear authorization from Congress.
Details of the decision
Judge Katherine Polk Failla denied most of Coinbase’s motions, finding that the regulator had brought “reasonable” charges against the exchange. She set an April 19 deadline for both sides to agree on a plan to organize the case. While the judge said the SEC appeared to have reason to believe that certain tokens listed on Wallet might qualify as an "investment contract," Coinbase did not appear to be acting as a brokerage and dismissed that portion of the lawsuit. She ruled that other aspects of the lawsuit could proceed, rejecting claims that the SEC violated the material issues doctrine or the Administrative Procedure Act.
Coinbase Chief Legal Officer Paul Grewal said: Early-stage motions like ours against government agencies are almost always denied. We encourage the U.S. Congress to continue advancing comprehensive U.S. digital asset legislation as it continues this process and any necessary appeals. This is critical if innovation is to stay in the United States. We also appreciate the court’s understanding that technological innovations such as the Coinbase Wallet do not and cannot implicate U.S. securities laws.
Future Direction
The case is currently in the trial stage, and the final verdict is still uncertain, and there are different opinions on the direction of the case. Former U.S. federal prosecutor and Cahill Gordon & Reindel LLP partner Samson Enzer predicted on January 27 that the judge would not dismiss the SEC v. Coinbase case at this stage because the threshold for the SEC to bring charges sufficient to obtain evidence disclosure is very high. Low. Enzer said the question for the court now is whether there is enough evidence to make a viable claim and then proceed with discovery, assuming the SEC's position holds.
JW Verret, a former SEC advisory committee member, said after winning the XRP case in 2023 that the court’s decision in the XRP case will greatly improve Coinbase’s chances of winning in court proceedings against the SEC. Elliott Stein, a senior litigation analyst at Bloomberg, predicted in January that Coinbase would win in its lawsuit against the SEC. He believed that Coinbase’s definition of “investment contract” is more precise than that provided by the SEC, which may be a turning point in the case. He also mentioned that the ruling in the Ripple v. SEC case could have a positive impact on Coinbase’s lawsuit.
Fox reporter Eleanor Terrett believes there won't be a clear "victory" here until the case is concluded. But in this ruling, there was a victory for both sides. The SEC successfully convinced Judge Failla that it had a reasonable basis for most of Coinbase’s claims. But equally, Coinbase may have convinced her during the discovery process. Failla also agreed with Coinbase’s claims regarding the wallet. The good news for all parties involved is that Judge Failla actually knows a lot about cryptoassets/Web3 and realizes the importance of the outcome of her case.
The above is the detailed content of Coinbase is caught in a litigation whirlpool: background of the case, details of the judgment and future direction. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Hot AI Tools

Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free

Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover

AI Hentai Generator
Generate AI Hentai for free.

Hot Article

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1
Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version
Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1
Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6
Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version
God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

Hot Topics

This article provides a detailed Gate.io registration tutorial, covering every step from accessing the official website to completing registration, including filling in registration information, verifying, reading user agreements, etc. The article also emphasizes security measures after successful registration, such as setting up secondary verification and completing real-name authentication, and gives tips from beginners to help users safely start their digital asset trading journey.

1. Enter the web version of okx Euyi Exchange ☜☜☜☜☜☜ Click to save 2. Click the link of okx Euyi Exchange app ☜☜☜☜ Click to save 3. After entering the official website, the clear interface provides a login and registration portal. Users can choose to log in to an existing account or register a new account according to their own situation. Whether it is viewing real-time market conditions, conducting transactions, or managing assets, the OKX web version provides a simple and smooth operating experience, suitable for beginners and veterans. Visit OKX official website now for easy experience

This article provides a detailed Gate.io web version latest registration tutorial to help users easily get started with digital asset trading. The tutorial covers every step from accessing the official website to completing registration, and emphasizes security settings after registration. The article also briefly introduces other trading platforms such as Binance, Ouyi and Sesame Open Door. It is recommended that users choose the right platform according to their own needs and pay attention to investment risks.

This article details how to use the official web version of OK exchange to log in. Users only need to search for "OK Exchange Official Web Version" in their browser, click the login button in the upper right corner after entering the official website, and enter the user name and password to log in. Registered users can easily manage assets, conduct transactions, deposit and withdraw funds, etc. The official website interface is simple and easy to use, and provides complete customer service support to ensure that users have a smooth digital asset trading experience. What are you waiting for? Visit the official website of OK Exchange now to start your digital asset journey!

This article introduces the basic information of Ouyi OKX trading platform and the installation steps of Android mobile client. Founded in 2017, Ouyi OKX is formerly OKEx, headquartered in Seychelles, providing coin trading, leveraged trading, options, delivery and perpetual contracts to tens of millions of users in more than 200 countries and regions around the world. The article elaborates on four steps from downloading the installation package to completing the installation, so that users can quickly get started with the OKX Android client. If you want to know the installation method of Ouyi OKX trading platform and Android client, please continue to read this article.

Based on market data and common evaluation criteria, this article lists the top ten formal Web3 trading platform APPs in 2025. The list covers well-known platforms such as Binance, OKX, Gate.io, Huobi (now known as HTX), Crypto.com, Coinbase, Kraken, Gemini, BitMEX and Bybit. These platforms have their own advantages in user scale, transaction volume, security, compliance, product innovation, etc. For example, Binance is known for its huge user base and rich product services, while Coinbase focuses on security and compliance. Choosing a suitable platform requires comprehensive consideration based on your own needs and risk tolerance.

This article recommends ten well-known virtual currency-related APP recommendation websites, including Binance Academy, OKX Learn, CoinGecko, CryptoSlate, CoinDesk, Investopedia, CoinMarketCap, Huobi University, Coinbase Learn and CryptoCompare. These websites not only provide information such as virtual currency market data, price trend analysis, etc., but also provide rich learning resources, including basic blockchain knowledge, trading strategies, and tutorials and reviews of various trading platform APPs, helping users better understand and make use of them

This article provides newbies with detailed Gate.io registration tutorials, guiding them to gradually complete the registration process, including accessing the official website, filling in information, identity verification, etc., and emphasizes the security settings after registration. In addition, the article also mentioned other exchanges such as Binance, Ouyi and Sesame Open Door. It is recommended that novices choose the right platform according to their own needs, and remind readers that digital asset investment is risky and should invest rationally.